Criminal Cases - FAQs
What should I do if I'm arrested?
If you're arrested: - Remain calm and polite - Remember you have the right to remain silent - Clearly state that you want to speak to your attorney - Do not discuss your case with anyone except your lawyer - Do not sign any documents without legal advice - Remember or write down details about your arrest if possible - Contact a family member or friend to help arrange legal representation
I'm innocent of the criminal charges against me. Why do I need a defense attorney when I can explain my innocence to the court myself?
Understanding your criminal defense rights and options is crucial for protecting your future. Let us explain why professional legal representation matters, even when you know you're innocent: Legal System Navigation The South African criminal justice system operates through specific procedures, rules of evidence, and legal frameworks. Your truthful account of events must be presented according to these established rules to be properly considered by the court. A defense attorney ensures your version is heard effectively within these legal parameters. Protecting Your Rights Your attorney serves as your legal shield throughout the criminal justice process. They oversee: •The proper handling of evidence •Legal questioning procedures •Protection of your constitutional rights •Adherence to criminal procedure •Preservation of your legal remedies Building Your Defense Early legal representation strengthens your position by: •Professionally gathering and preserving evidence •Conducting lawful witness interviews •Identifying necessary expert witnesses •Examining the strength of the State's case •Preparing comprehensive trial strategy Court Procedure Management Criminal courts follow strict protocols. Your attorney handles: •Evidence presentation •Witness examination •Legal objections •Procedural requirements •Court submissions •Case law application Financial Considerations We understand that legal fees can be concerning. Our firm: •Offers transparent fee structures •Discusses payment arrangements •Provides detailed cost breakdowns •Works with clients to find manageable payment solutions Case Resolution Options Professional representation opens various resolution pathways: •Early case evaluation •Alternative dispute resolution where appropriate •Negotiation with prosecution when beneficial •Trial preparation when necessary •Strategic case planning Long-term Protection A criminal charge requires careful handling to protect your: •Criminal record •Employment prospects •Professional licenses •Travel abilities •Future opportunities Our Commitment At [Firm Name], we believe everyone deserves skilled legal representation. We invite you to schedule a consultation to discuss: •Your specific case details •Available defense strategies •Cost structures •Timeline expectations •Potential outcomes Contact us at [contact details] to arrange your consultation. Our experienced criminal defense team is ready to protect your rights and present your case effectively within the South African justice system.
When does a person need a criminal defence attorney?
You should contact a criminal defense attorney if: - You've been arrested - The police want to question you - You've been charged with a crime - You're under investigation - You've received a summons to appear in court - You believe you might be under investigation Early legal representation often leads to better outcomes, so don't wait until your court date approaches.
How much does criminal defence representation cost?
TJC Dunn Attorneys will always discuss fees transparently with you. Legal fees vary depending on: - The type and complexity of your case - Whether it's a first alleged offence or repeat allged offence - The court where your case will be heard - Expected duration of the case - Whether the matter goes to trial
What's the difference between a first appearance, bail hearing, and trial?
First Appearance: Your first court appearance where charges are formally read and you can apply for bail if in custody. Bail Hearing: Where the court decides whether to release you pending trial and under what conditions. Trial: The formal court process where evidence is presented and your case is decided.
The police want to interview me but haven't arrested me. What should I do?
If the police want to interview you, it's usually best to decline until you've consulted with an attorney. Even if you're innocent and want to explain your side, police interviews can be complex and potentially dangerous to your legal interests. Politely inform the police that you wish to speak with an attorney first. This is your legal right and cannot be used against you in court.
Can the police search my home or car without a warrant?
Picture this: The South African Police Service (SAPS) officers arrive at your door wanting to search your property without a warrant. Is this legal under South African law? Here's what you need to know: SAPS can conduct searches without a warrant in two key situations: When you say "yes": Just like letting someone into your home, you (or whoever has authority over the property) can give permission for both the search and for SAPS to take specific items. This is your constitutional right to choose. When time is critical: Given South Africa's unique crime challenges, SAPS officers sometimes face urgent situations. They can search without a warrant when two things are true: They have reasonable grounds to believe a magistrate would approve a warrant if they applied for one, AND The evidence might disappear or be destroyed if they wait for a warrant. For example, if someone might destroy evidence while the officer travels to the courthouse in heavy Cape Town traffic. Here's the bottom line: While SAPS does have these powers under Section 22 of the Criminal Procedure Act, they must still respect your constitutional rights and follow proper procedures. Every case is different, and if you're unsure whether a warrantless search was conducted lawfully, don't hesitate to contact us. Our experienced criminal law attorneys can review your specific situation and help protect your rights under South African law. Remember: The Constitution protects your right to privacy, and understanding these rights is essential in our democratic South Africa. If you have questions about a search, contact us at 083 495 1261 for expert legal guidance. Tip: Keep a record of what happened during any police search, including the names or badge numbers of the officers involved, and contact a lawyer as soon as possible if you have concerns.
What's the difference between Legal Aid and a private attorney?
In South Africa, Legal Aid provides government-funded legal representation for those who cannot afford private attorneys. Whilst Legal Aid attorneys are qualified legal professionals, they often manage large caseloads, which can affect their availability. Private attorneys typically have more time to dedicate to your case and can provide more personalized attention. However, Legal Aid attorneys are experienced in criminal defence and are well-versed in representing clients in our courts. To qualify for Legal Aid, you must pass a means test that evaluates your income and assets. If you don't qualify for Legal Aid but cannot afford a private attorney's full fees, some attorneys offer payment plans or reduced rates.
What happens at the first court appearance?
In South African courts, your first appearance in a Criminal Court is crucial. The prosecutor will present the charges, and you'll have the opportunity to apply for bail if you haven't already been released. You won't usually be asked to plead at this first appearance unless it's a minor offence. If you are asked to plead, it is advisable to indicate that you will be pleading ‘not guilty’. The Magistrate will ensure you understand your rights, including your right to legal representation. If you need time to arrange a private attorney or apply for Legal Aid, you can request a postponement. The court will also set a date for your next appearance. It's important to have an attorney present at this stage to protect your interests and guide you through the process.
Can the police use my social media against me?
Yes, police can use public social media posts as evidence. They might also obtain private messages through search warrants. It's advisable to avoid posting about your case on social media and to review your privacy settings. Consider temporarily deactivating your accounts after consulting with your attorney.
Who can I talk to about my case?
You should only discuss your case with your attorney, as these conversations are protected by attorney-client privilege. Avoid discussing your case with family, friends, or on social media, as these conversations aren't privileged and could be used against you. Your attorney can advise you on what information can be safely shared with others.
I've been accused of domestic violence - what should I know about these charges?
In South Africa, domestic violence charges are taken very seriously under the Domestic Violence Act. If you're accused, you may face both criminal charges and a protection order. Do not contact the complainant, as this could result in additional charges. Your communications might be monitored or recorded. If you need to arrange matters like collecting belongings or child visitation, do this through your attorney. Remember that even if the complainant wants to withdraw charges, this decision rests with the prosecutor, not the complainant. Secure legal representation immediately, as these cases can significantly impact child custody rights and future employment opportunities.
Am I allowed to record SAPS members while they're on duty?
Yes, you have the legal right to record SAPS members performing their duties in public spaces. This right is protected under South African law and supports transparency and accountability. However, exercise this right respectfully and safely. Film from a reasonable distance that doesn't interfere with police work. Keep your hands visible and clearly state that you are recording. If ordered to stop, you can politely state your right to record but avoid confrontation. Back up recordings immediately to cloud storage if possible, as they might be crucial evidence later.
What should I do with recordings of police interactions?
If you've recorded police interactions, immediately make multiple copies and store them securely. Send a copy to your attorney or a trusted person. Don't edit or alter the recording in any way, as this could affect its evidential value. If the recording shows misconduct, your attorney can help you file a formal complaint with IPID (Independent Police Investigative Directorate) or use it in legal proceedings. Keep detailed notes about when and where the recording was made, and who was present.
Why is it important to write down my version of events immediately?
Writing down your version of events as soon as possible is crucial for several reasons. Human memory fades and changes over time, especially during stressful events. A contemporaneous (immediate) written account provides the most accurate version of events and can be powerful evidence in court. Include every detail you can remember, no matter how minor it seems. Note weather conditions, lighting, what people were wearing, exact words used, and the sequence of events. This document can help your attorney build your defense and might reveal important details you could forget later. Keep this document private and share it only with your attorney.
How should I document my version of events?
The duration of a criminal case varies significantly depending on its complexity, the court's schedule, and the strategy chosen. Simple cases might resolve in a few months, while complex cases can take a year or longer. Factors that affect timing include the number of witnesses, the amount of evidence to review, whether experts are needed, and if plea negotiations are ongoing. Your attorney can give you a better estimate based on your specific circumstances.
What should I do if I'm injured while in police custody?
If you're injured in police custody, seek immediate medical attention. This creates an official record of your injuries. Ask the medical staff to document all injuries thoroughly with photographs if possible. Report the incident to the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) as soon as possible. Write down every detail you can remember about the incident, including names or identifying features of officers involved. Keep all medical records and photographs. Your attorney can help file necessary complaints and preserve evidence for potential civil claims.
What if I'm injured by someone else but police refuse to take my statement?
If police refuse to take your statement, document their refusal. Note the station, date, time, and names of officers if possible. Request to speak with the station commander. You can also go to another police station to file your complaint. Visit a doctor or hospital immediately to document your injuries - medical records are crucial evidence. Contact your attorney, who can help ensure your case is properly recorded and investigated. Remember you can also file complaints with IPID about police failure to assist.
What should I do if a police officer hints at wanting a bribe?
If you suspect a police officer is soliciting a bribe, remain calm and discrete. If possible, activate your phone's voice recorder without being obvious. Never explicitly offer or agree to a bribe, as this is itself a crime. Take mental notes of the officer's name, badge number, vehicle number, and physical description. Contact your attorney immediately. Your attorney can help report the incident to the Independent Police Investigative Directorate (IPID) and advise on gathering evidence safely. Remember that your safety comes first - if you feel threatened, focus on staying safe and report the incident as soon as possible.
How can I protect myself from police corruption?
Keep your attorney's number written on paper in your wallet - phones are often confiscated during arrest. Consider installing an app that can record audio with a screen-off quick launch feature. Learn your basic rights under Section 35 of the Constitution. Keep a small notebook and pen in your car to document any incidents immediately. If approached by police, be polite but firm about your rights. Ask for identification and write down badge numbers. If possible, conduct any interaction in view of cameras or witnesses. Never carry large amounts of cash that might create opportunities for corruption.
Why should I carry an attorney's business card or number on paper?
When arrested, your phone and belongings are usually confiscated, leaving you unable to access contact numbers stored in your phone. Having your attorney's number written on paper in your wallet ensures you can exercise your constitutional right to legal representation immediately. This is crucial as the first hours after arrest are often critical to your case. Even if you've never been in legal trouble, circumstances like car accidents, domestic disputes, or being a witness to a crime can result in unexpected police interaction where legal representation is vital.
Should I answer questions from medical staff during a DUI blood test?
While medical staff may ask about what you've consumed, you have the right to remain silent. These questions are part of gathering evidence and your answers can be used against you in court. Politely decline to answer questions about food, drink, or medication consumption. Only provide necessary medical information (like allergies or medical conditions that might affect the blood draw). Your attorney should be present for any questioning. Remember that while you must submit to the blood test if requested by an authorized officer, you don't have to provide additional information that might incriminate you.
What details should I notice and remember during any police interaction?
Pay attention to officer names, badge numbers, vehicle numbers, time, location, and any witnesses present. Notice if there are nearby security cameras. Remember the sequence of events and exact words used. If you're taken to a police station, note which station and the names of officers you interact with. This information can be crucial for your defense or any complaints about police conduct. Write these details down as soon as you can, noting the date and time you made the record.

